Skip to content
Health

Cass review author opposes current draft conversion practices bill

Baroness Cass, who led the review into gender identity services, tells a parliamentary committee she does not back the current wording.

Palace of Westminster in 2022
File photo, 2022: Palace of Westminster. Photo: Terry Ott from Washington, DC Metro Area, United States of America / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0 (cropped)

Key points

  • Baroness Cass, who wrote the independent review of gender identity care for young people, does not back the current draft bill, according to BBC News
  • She had earlier welcomed the bill and was quoted in government publicity in June
  • She warned the wording could lead to vexatious complaints and prosecution of therapists
  • The government says it will take the committee's evidence seriously

Baroness Cass, who led the examination of gender identity care for young people, has told a parliamentary committee that she does not support the current draft bill banning conversion practices. According to BBC News, she had previously welcomed the proposal. Her position now marks a clear shift.

Asked directly at the Draft Conversion Practices Bill committee whether she backed the bill in its present form, she answered with a single word: “no”. She said the wording could cause serious unintended consequences for parents of children experiencing gender distress and for medical professionals working in that area.

The government has said the bill is meant to protect LGBT people in England and Wales. In general terms, the phrase covers therapies, procedures and other activities intended to alter or repress a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity. These efforts can take place within faith communities or at home, and they may cause deep distress to the person involved.

Concerns about the wording

The draft requires proof of serious harm to a person’s physical or mental health, or serious alarm or distress with a substantial adverse effect on daily life. Baroness Cass said this wording could allow vexatious complaints. She warned that such complaints could expose therapists who work with young people experiencing gender distress to the risk of prosecution.

She also said that staff at the new NHS Gender Dysphoria Clinics were worried that complaints which never led to prosecution could still do damage. As an example, she described a young person who had been sexually abused. Discussing that experience could be highly distressing, she said, yet therapeutic work may be hard to carry out without referring to it.

Possible effects on families

Baroness Cass raised concerns about families as well. She suggested that a parent who stopped a child’s money because they thought the child might buy a breast binder or hormones could fall within the scope of the bill and face prosecution.

She said she had supported the idea of the bill when it was first published but had not read the details before the press release went out. She remains firmly opposed to subjecting LGBT people to these practices. In her 2024 report she had described such practices as “abhorrent”.

Government response and next steps

A government spokesperson said it welcomed her support for ending abusive conversion practices and her points on avoiding adverse consequences. The government said it wanted to get the ban right and would take all evidence from the committee seriously. It described the bill as a way to end almost a decade of delay for LGBT people.

The committee hearings are continuing. The bill has not yet become law, and its final wording remains open to change.

Frequently asked questions

Why does Baroness Cass oppose the current draft bill?

She told a parliamentary committee that the current wording risks serious unintended consequences. She warned it could allow vexatious complaints that put therapists at risk of prosecution.

What are conversion practices?

The phrase covers therapies, procedures and other activities intended to alter or repress a personu0026#039;s sexual orientation or gender identity. These can take place within faith communities or at home.

What has the government said in response?

The government welcomed Baroness Cassu0026#039;s comments and said it would take all committee evidence seriously. It said it wants to get the ban right.

Sources

This article was written with the help of AI from reports by the outlets listed above. See our Editorial Policy. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.

About the author

Ravi Franklin

Founder & Editor

Ravi Franklin is the founder and editor of Peak Journalism. His background is in graphic design and digital content, and he started Peak Journalism to make global news clear and easy to follow.