Skip to content
Breaking
Health

Aberdeen surgeon seeks homicide probe into NHS Grampian deaths

A whistleblowing consultant alleges avoidable patient deaths over many years. The health board has not yet responded to the latest claims.

Peak Journalism news card: Aberdeen surgeon seeks homicide probe into NHS Grampian deaths

Key points

  • Consultant surgeon Mohammed Habib wants a corporate homicide investigation into NHS Grampian
  • A 2022 external review found 19 avoidable deaths among 45 liver and pancreatic surgery patients
  • Healthcare Improvement Scotland recently reported major deficiencies at the regional board
  • NHS Grampian's management has not yet commented on the new allegations
  • The Scottish government says it is giving the health board unprecedented support

According to the BBC, Dr Mohammed Habib works as a consultant surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary and is now pressing for a probe into possible corporate homicide. He alleges that NHS Grampian patients have died avoidably over many years. The health board has not yet responded to these latest claims.

Habib, who remains employed at the hospital, spoke at a media event on Thursday alongside his representative, the lawyer and rights campaigner Aamer Anwar. Habib has been on the NHS Grampian staff since 2014. He says he is risking his career to hold the health board to account.

A leaked review with troubling findings

Habib has leaked a 2022 expert review that has never been published. The review covered 45 patients receiving liver and pancreatic care at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary between 2015 and 2021. Of those, 31 died, and reviewers judged 19 deaths to be avoidable outcomes of surgery or other intervention. Some patients reportedly bled to death during operations because of surgeons’ errors.

The review measured death rates after major liver resections. Between 2017 and 2020, 12 per cent of patients died within 30 days and 18 per cent within 90 days. The expected figure was 2.2 per cent. Reviewers also called blood loss in both liver and pancreatic operations unacceptably high, and pointed to weak planning and unclear standards.

A second report and last week’s findings

A later external report this year described similar problems. Its authors said surgical decisions showed poor judgement about risk, and that major blood losses and deaths kept recurring. They concluded the issues were long-running, that the unit lacked enough specialist staff, and that concerns had been flagged since 2010. They strongly advised against complex liver, pancreas and bile duct operations at the Aberdeen site.

Last week, Healthcare Improvement Scotland published findings of serious shortcomings across the region. It said repeated avoidable harm to patients had followed from the board’s weak learning from errors. Health Secretary Angela Constance responded that hospitals were safe and promised openness at every level.

Government and whistleblower accounts

A Scottish government spokesperson praised the bravery of the whistleblower. The government described its help for NHS Grampian as intensive and unprecedented in scale. Habib says he formally raised concerns about dozens of avoidable deaths in 2021, and that he first became aware of such deaths in 2016. In 2024 he gave police details of 20 cases from the previous decade, but no charges followed. He says the Scottish government told him it lacked power to examine whistleblowing complaints, and that the Independent Whistleblowing Officer declined to take forward his complaints.

Habib believes several hundred patients have been harmed by an unusually high rate of complications, although that estimate is his own and has not been verified. He also wrote in December 2025 to chief executive Laura Skaife Knight. Her reply asked him to allow Healthcare Improvement Scotland to finish its inquiries, saying she had nothing further to add at that stage. Habib accused the board of avoiding accountability by withholding information on the damage done.

Frequently asked questions

What is NHS Grampian being accused of?

Consultant surgeon Mohammed Habib alleges avoidable deaths among patients over many years. He has called for a corporate homicide investigation, and the health board has not yet commented on the new claims.

What did the 2022 review find?

The review looked at 45 liver and pancreatic patients at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary. It concluded that 19 deaths were considered avoidable consequences of surgery or intervention.

What has the Scottish government said?

A Scottish government spokesperson praised the courage of the whistleblower. It said the health board was receiving a very significant level of intervention and support.

Sources

This article was written with the help of AI from reports by the outlets listed above. See our Editorial Policy. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.

About the author

Ravi Franklin

Founder & Editor

Ravi Franklin is the founder and editor of Peak Journalism. His background is in graphic design and digital content, and he started Peak Journalism to make global news clear and easy to follow.