Newly engaged reader torn over feelings for an old friend
A reader weighs whether to share new feelings for a long-time friend, and an adviser urges a close look at what those feelings really mean.

Key points
- A newly engaged reader has written to The Guardian's advice column, Leading questions.
- The writer learned that a long-time friend has held romantic feelings for them for years.
- The friend is also engaged and does not know how the writer now feels.
- Eleanor advises the reader to examine whether the feelings reflect a real wish for change.
- She warns that telling the friend could cause harm to several people.
A reader who is newly engaged has written to The Guardian’s advice column, Leading questions, asking whether to tell an old friend about new feelings. The writer says the engagement followed a fast-moving romance and that the proposal brought great happiness. They describe their partner as kind, generous and caring.
The writer later learned that a friend they have known for years had long held romantic feelings for them. That news has changed how they see this friend, and they now question whether they should still marry their partner. The friend has recently become engaged himself and has no idea how the writer feels.
The adviser’s response
Eleanor, the column’s adviser, asks the reader to think carefully about why the discovery has shifted their view. She asks whether the reader was unhappy in the relationship beforehand, or whether they had felt drawn to the friend before. If neither was true, she suggests that the strength of the new feeling may not be a reliable guide to what is accurate.
She also explains that major commitments, such as marriage, close off other possible paths. Before a decision is made, the mind can picture several futures at once. After a commitment, those alternatives fade, and that loss can feel painful even when the choice is sound. A reminder of other possibilities can make a new person seem especially appealing at such moments.
Eleanor notes that moving back into the stage of weighing options can bring a sense of freedom. In that state, a person may feel that their life still holds many paths. She suggests the reader consider whether they are responding to the friend himself, or to what he represents at a time of major change.
Risks of speaking out
Eleanor warns that telling the friend could cause real harm to the writer’s partner, to the friend, and to the friend’s fiancée. She points out that the friend’s past feelings did not stop him from planning a future with someone else. She also says it is not clear whether those feelings could support a marriage.
She puts the choice in simple terms. Would the reader be willing to give up a good and secure relationship for an uncertain chance of something better? In her view, most people would not make that trade. If the idea feels tempting, she suggests it may signal that the reader is not fully confident in the current relationship.
- The column stresses that strong feelings can carry important messages, but not always the ones they seem to.
- The adviser suggests looking beneath the surface to understand what the feeling is really revealing.
- No outcome is confirmed, and the reader has not said what they will decide.
Why the question resonates
Personal dilemmas of this kind are common in advice columns, where readers ask how to handle emotions during major life changes. The column does not give a single answer. Instead, it encourages the reader to slow down, examine their motives, and weigh the value of the commitment they already have.
The column is published in The Guardian’s lifestyle section and invites readers to submit their own questions. It offers general guidance rather than a verdict on any individual’s situation.
Frequently asked questions
What is the reader asking for advice about?
The reader is engaged to a partner they describe as kind and generous. They have developed strong feelings for a long-time friend and are unsure whether to tell him or to continue with the wedding plans.
What does Eleanor suggest the reader should consider?
Eleanor suggests the reader ask why the discovery changed their view and whether they were unhappy or attracted to the friend before. She also warns that telling the friend could harm several people.
Why does Eleanor say big commitments can feel difficult?
According to Eleanor, a major commitment such as marriage closes off other possible futures. Even a sound choice can bring a sense of loss for the paths not taken.
Sources
- The Guardian: I’m engaged but I can’t stop thinking about an old friend. Should I tell him how I feel? | Leading questions
This article was written with the help of AI from reports by the outlets listed above. See our Editorial Policy. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.



