Skip to content
Breaking
U.S.

Judge rules Trump’s $15bn claim against the Times can continue

A Florida judge dismissed two claims but allowed the core defamation case to continue. The Times and Penguin Random House deny the allegations.

Donald Trump state visit to Saudi Arabia, 2025-05-13 PDT-1009
File photo, 2025. Photo: The White House / Wikimedia Commons (The White House), Public domain (cropped)

Key points

  • A federal judge in Florida ruled that Trump's suit can move ahead.
  • Judge Steven Merryday dismissed two claims but kept the central defamation allegations.
  • The suit targets three New York Times reporters and a 2024 book.
  • The New York Times and Penguin Random House deny defaming Trump.

A federal judge in Florida has let Donald Trump’s suit against the New York Times and Penguin Random House move ahead, as reported by The Guardian, with contributions from Reuters. The ruling came on Thursday. It is a win for the president in his broader effort to pursue media companies he believes have been unfair to him. The suit seeks $15bn.

Steven Merryday, a US district judge sitting in Tampa, threw out two of the claims. The central defamation allegations will continue through the courts.

Read also: Musk says he is not MAGA and regrets midterm spending

What the lawsuit alleges

The defamation allegations are aimed at three reporters from the Times: Susanne Craig, Russ Buettner and Peter Baker. Trump points to two newspaper articles and a 2024 book, Lucky Loser, which Craig and Buettner wrote together. He contends that the material contains untrue statements that harmed both his commercial interests and his standing as an individual.

Of the statements he challenges, 22 come from Baker’s book and 12 appear in the work of the other two reporters. They concern Trump’s part in building The Apprentice, the money passed on by his father, his commercial dealings, and his childhood in New York.

Earlier steps in the case

The case has been through several stages. A first filing of 80 pages was thrown out by the court, which found it too long, lacking a brief overview, and written in harsh, insulting language. A revised filing of 40 pages came in October last year and dropped mentions of the 2024 presidential race.

Attempts at mediation did not resolve the dispute. The defendants’ request to shift the case to federal court in New York also failed.

The judge’s reasoning and the response

Dismissing two claims, Merryday found that the rest of the complaint offered a credible basis for its position. He said accusations that Trump planned and carried out elaborate crimes rested on limited, scant information.

The Times and Penguin Random House reject the claim that they defamed Trump. In a filing, the defendants argued that the case has legal weaknesses and seeks to gain political advantage.

Times spokesperson Charlie Stadtlander earlier described the suit as plainly without merit. A spokesperson for Penguin Random House also called it without merit and affirmed backing for the book and the authors who wrote it.

Neither company had replied to press inquiries about the latest decision at the time of reporting.

Why the case matters

The ruling allows the suit to move into the next stage of litigation. It does not decide whether the allegations are true, and no finding on the merits has been made.

The case is one of several legal actions the president has brought against news organisations, according to the source reporting.

Frequently asked questions

What did the judge decide?

Steven Merryday, a US district judge in Tampa, Florida, threw out two claims. The rest of the defamation case will continue.

Who is named in the lawsuit?

The suit names the New York Times and Penguin Random House. Three Times reporters, Susanne Craig, Russ Buettner and Peter Baker, are also named in the claims.

How did the defendants respond?

Both companies deny defaming Trump and argue the case has legal weaknesses. Penguin Random House has said it backs the book and its authors.

Sources

This article was written with the help of AI from reports by the outlets listed above. See our Editorial Policy. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.

About the author

Ravi Franklin

Founder & Editor

Ravi Franklin is the founder and editor of Peak Journalism. His background is in graphic design and digital content, and he started Peak Journalism to make global news clear and easy to follow.