Skip to content
U.S.

New York City proposes ban on boiling lobsters alive

A city council bill would stop restaurants from cooking crustaceans alive, citing animal welfare concerns and similar rules in other countries.

New York City Hall in 2007
File photo, 2007: New York City Hall. Photo: Momos / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0 (cropped)

Key points

  • Bronx Democrat Oswald Feliz and Harvey Epstein sponsored the proposed legislation in the city council
  • Restaurants would be barred from cooking crustaceans alive in boiling water, according to the proposal
  • No fine applies to a first violation, while repeat violations could bring civil fines of up to $100 each
  • Switzerland, Norway and New Zealand already restrict boiling lobsters alive without stunning them first

New York City lawmakers have proposed banning restaurants from boiling lobsters alive, according to The Guardian. The bill was introduced in the city council by Bronx Democrat Oswald Feliz and Harvey Epstein, who represents lower Manhattan. The measure is still a proposal and would take effect only if it passes.

Under the plan, eateries could no longer cook crustaceans such as lobsters and crabs by lowering them alive into boiling water. Serving lobster or crab prepared in other ways would remain allowed.

Penalties would be staged. A first offence would not lead to any fine. Repeat offences could result in charges of as much as $100 for each violation, handled as a civil matter.

Why the sponsors say the bill is needed

The sponsors cite recent scientific research suggesting that crustaceans commonly served in restaurants feel intense pain when boiled alive without being stunned beforehand. This reasoning appears in a memo that accompanies the legislation.

The memo adds that many nations, mainly in Europe, have outlawed this method in recent years. It states that New York City should ensure animals are consumed ethically and not forced to endure needless suffering.

Switzerland, Norway and New Zealand already have rules barring the practice unless lobsters are knocked unconscious first. The UK government has similarly said that cooking conscious lobsters alive will be prohibited as part of a wider animal welfare plan.

British ministers have described cooking lobsters while they are still alive as unacceptable as a killing method, a position they voiced last December.

Humane methods proposed

The Cornwall Good Seafood Guide offers a few options before cooking. One is keeping the creature in a cold freezer for a set period of 15 to 20 minutes, or surrounding it with crushed ice.

Once the animal has entered a sleep-like state, the guide says it can be killed humanely by cutting through the main nerves and then letting the blood drain.

A quicker option, according to the same guide, is slicing down the belly midline from head to tail. Crabs need another approach, piercing the underside to disable the principal nerve. Norwegian researchers have additionally put forward electrocution as a possible method.

Part of a wider debate

In a comment to the New York Post, Feliz described boiling creatures while they are still alive as a textbook example of cruelty to animals. He also challenged the notion that lobsters feel no pain, pointing out that they struggle and try to get away when dropped into boiling water.

The bill is the newest attempt by city lawmakers to limit food practices on animal welfare grounds. A separate proposal to ban foie gras sales has become entangled in a dispute between the city and state government.

Earlier this year, Letitia James, the state attorney general, asked the top state court to weigh whether the city’s foie gras ban should be paused. She argued that it places farms in agricultural districts at risk.

Frequently asked questions

What would the New York City bill do?

The proposal would stop eateries from putting lobsters, crabs and similar shellfish into boiling water while they are alive. Dishes prepared by other methods would still be allowed.

What penalties would the bill set?

No fine applies to a first offence. Later violations could be handled as civil matters with charges of as much as $100 each, the legislation proposes.

Who sponsored the lobster bill?

Co-backers of the measure are Oswald Feliz, a Democrat from the Bronx, and Harvey Epstein, who represents lower Manhattan. It was introduced in the city council.

Sources

This article was written with the help of AI from reports by the outlets listed above. See our Editorial Policy. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.

About the author

Ravi Franklin

Founder & Editor

Ravi Franklin is the founder and editor of Peak Journalism. His background is in graphic design and digital content, and he started Peak Journalism to make global news clear and easy to follow.