Skip to content
Politics

Lords report warns UK is underprepared for linked crises

Peers say ministers must act fast on cyber threats, supply chains and emergency planning, while the government says it is already moving at speed.

Peak Journalism news card: Lords report warns UK is underprepared for linked crises

Key points

  • A Lords national resilience committee report says the UK government appears complacent about emerging threats.
  • Medicines and food supply chains are highly centralised, with few back-up options if disrupted.
  • The report urges a dedicated cabinet minister and a national resilience strategy within six months.
  • It recommends a household emergency booklet, following models used in Denmark and Sweden.
  • The Cabinet Office says it will carefully review the recommendations.

According to The Guardian, a parliamentary report has found that ministers are complacent about fast-changing threats to the UK. The Lords national resilience committee says the government must act quickly to strengthen national resilience against possibly very major crises. The committee warned that the country is underprepared.

The report says most of the public is unaware of the scale of potential dangers. These include cyber-attacks, proxy acts of violence, damage to undersea cables, and natural disasters such as extreme weather and flooding. The committee noted that the Labour government recently launched its “Be Ready” campaign, which advises households to keep stocks of food and water.

Calls for a new approach

The committee, which spent months holding expert hearings, wants a single and coherent approach to resilience planning. It argues that one senior minister should hold a specific post in the cabinet with responsibility for this area. It also wants the prime minister to address parliament each year on how prepared the country is. A further suggestion is that every household receive a booklet explaining how to prepare for and respond to emergencies, similar to schemes in Denmark and Sweden.

The report argues that current plans are often out of date and too narrow. They tend to address single emergencies, such as a loss of power or water, or a cyber-attack. They do not account for a growing “polycrisis” in which several disruptions overlap. The committee said artificial intelligence could increase the risk from cyber-attacks.

The committee also called for more flexible ways to reach the public. One proposal is to hold off on the planned shutdown of the terrestrial television broadcast network, which resembles Freeview, in case other communication systems fail.

Supply chain weaknesses

The report highlights medicines and food as particular concerns. Most antibiotic medicines are made in China or India, the report says. It states that about 90% of the world’s 6-APA, the compound used as the basis of penicillin-type antibiotics, comes from China. The UK has no integrated penicillin facility, and Europe has only one.

Other medical supplies face similar reliance on overseas production. A witness told the committee that disruption to items such as scissors and medical staplers could badly affect many routine surgical operations.

On food, the committee was told that stockpiling several days of supplies, as Be Ready recommends, does not address wider strategic risks. According to the report, almost 95% of UK retail food is supplied by just nine companies, operating from 131 distribution hubs. Disruption to a small number of firms could therefore cause very significant problems.

The report also raises concerns about digital communications. BT has a dominant role in this area, but the report found it has access to just two cable repair ships. One vessel is owned by a French company and is rarely available. The other is registered in the UK but is now three and a half decades old.

The committee also wants the Cabinet Office to produce a national resilience strategy within six months. It urges proper funding, a more coherent risk assessment, and a national list of volunteers and civil reservists. It also suggests paid leave for people who complete resilience training. The committee says emergency planning is currently organised in silos, and wants this to change.

Jean Coussins leads the committee as a crossbench member of the House of Lords. She argued that ministers should not shy away from describing the risks. In her view, the public would be reassured by candid information. A Cabinet Office spokesperson said the department would carefully review the recommendations. The spokesperson said the government had already taken rapid action, citing a national awareness campaign, a large home defence exercise next year, and more than £1bn invested in pandemic security. The government acknowledged that more work remains, including with allies.

Frequently asked questions

What did the Lords committee report find?

The report found that UK ministers appear complacent and that the country is underprepared for fast-changing threats. It said current emergency plans are often out of date and too fragmented.

What does the report recommend?

It recommends a dedicated cabinet minister, an annual prime ministerial statement to parliament, a national resilience strategy within six months, and a booklet for every household. It also suggests a national register of volunteers.

How has the government responded?

A Cabinet Office spokesperson said it would carefully review the recommendations. The government said it was already acting rapidly and that more work remains.

Sources

This article was written with the help of AI from reports by the outlets listed above. See our Editorial Policy. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.

About the author

Ravi Franklin

Founder & Editor

Ravi Franklin is the founder and editor of Peak Journalism. His background is in graphic design and digital content, and he started Peak Journalism to make global news clear and easy to follow.