How to choose a pillow for your sleep position and temperature
A months-long testing project by a Guardian product reviewer offers guidance on support, heat, filling and washing for different kinds of sleepers.

Key points
- A Guardian reviewer spent months testing pillows for different sleepers, as reported in the Filter US guide.
- Each pillow was compressed with a 20lb weight to measure support.
- Heat tests used warmed pads placed between a pillow and a towel for 20 minutes, read with a thermal camera.
- Loft choice depends on sleep position: side, back or stomach.
- Foam and latex generally handle heat better than real down.
A product reviewer writing for the Guardian has spent months testing pillows to find six top picks for different kinds of sleepers, according to the outlet’s Filter US guide. The writer argues that pillows deserve as much thought as shoes, tyres and mattresses, because the right one can decide whether a night is restful or restless.
The reviewer says they have tested and reviewed products for more than 13 years, and has written for Filter US since October 2025. Their earlier work included a product-testing lab, where they focused on washing machines, fabric care and sleep lab protocols.
How the pillows were tested
Each pillow had a 20lb weight placed at its centre, and the amount of compression was measured. The aim was to find pillows that give support without feeling hard, and that feel soft without swallowing the head.
To check temperature control, heating pads were warmed in a microwave for 15 seconds, bringing them to around 100F, roughly body temperature. Each pad then sat between a pillow and a folded towel for 20 minutes, and a thermal camera recorded how heat moved away from it.
Pillows that made specific claims from their brands were measured and checked against what the makers said they could do. Extra tests were run to see whether those promises held up in practice.
Choosing a pillow by sleep position and filling
Side sleepers are generally advised to look for higher-loft pillows that feel softer. Back sleepers tend to do better with medium-loft pillows that feel firmer, while stomach sleepers are usually most comfortable on low-loft pillows.
- Side sleepers: higher loft, softer feel.
- Back sleepers: medium loft, firmer feel.
- Stomach sleepers: low loft.
Pillows are usually filled with one of three materials. Foam gives strong support and good airflow. Latex and gel tend to last well and balance support with softness. Down and its alternatives feel soft, warm and easy to shape, but they offer less support than the other two.
Keeping hot sleepers cool
For people who run warm, foam and latex generally release heat better than real down, which tends to hold warmth in. A breathable, moisture-wicking pillowcase, such as one made of cotton or linen, can also help a sleeper stay comfortable.
Some pillows are sold as adjustable. These usually let the owner remove or add filling, so the height can be changed to suit the shape of the body and the position a person sleeps in.
Washing and care
Outer covers usually tolerate a machine wash on a delicate setting, provided the water is kept mildly warm and only a little cleaning liquid is added. Foam and latex interiors, by contrast, are limited to spot treatment, so they should not go through a full wash. Down-filled and down-substitute pillows, however, may frequently go through the machine intact.
The reviewer advises always checking the care label first and following its instructions. This simple step helps keep a pillow supportive for longer.
Why it matters
Sleep depends on many small choices, and the pillow is one that people often overlook. The guide frames its advice around posture, temperature and maintenance, rather than relying on brand names alone.
Readers are also pointed to related Filter pieces on sleep masks, a pillow filled with buckwheat hulls and weighted blankets.
Frequently asked questions
How were the pillows tested?
A 20lb weight was placed on each pillow to measure compression. Heat tests used warmed pads placed between a pillow and a folded towel for 20 minutes, with a thermal camera recording heat dissipation.
Which pillow suits my sleep position?
Side sleepers are advised to choose higher-loft, softer pillows. Back sleepers are best served by medium-loft, firmer pillows, and stomach sleepers are most comfortable on low-loft pillows.
How should I wash a pillow?
Most outer casings can be machine-washed on a gentle cycle with warm water and a little detergent. Foam and latex cores should only be spot-cleaned, and care tags should always be checked.
Sources
This article was written with the help of AI from reports by the outlets listed above. See our Editorial Policy. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.



