Skip to content
Breaking
U.S.

Susan Smith refused parole again 32 years after sons’ deaths

The board rejected her request at a hearing on Thursday, while the boys' father urged that she remain in prison.

Peak Journalism news card: Susan Smith refused parole again 32 years after sons' deaths

Key points

  • South Carolina's seven-member parole board unanimously denied Susan Smith's request for release, according to BBC News.
  • Smith, 55, was convicted in the 1994 deaths of her sons, Michael and Alex.
  • Smith told the board she had changed and said she was deeply sorry.
  • David Smith, the boys' father, attended the hearing and opposed her release.
  • Smith can apply for parole again every two years.

According to BBC News, a parole board in South Carolina has again refused to release Susan Smith from prison. Smith, 55, was convicted of murdering her two young sons in 1994. The seven-member board reached its decision unanimously at a hearing on Thursday.

Smith was convicted over the deaths of Michael, aged three, and Alex, aged one. She had placed both boys inside a vehicle, secured them in their child seats, and sent the car into a lake. The second denial of her parole comes 32 years after the killings.

What Smith told the board

Speaking at the hearing, Smith said that the moment she let the car roll into the lake was the lowest point of her life. She told the board that she had grown and changed since the crime. She also said she was very sorry and that she would reverse what happened if she could.

Smith said the boys were innocent and did not deserve to die. Her lawyers had previously argued that she suffered a mental breakdown when the crime took place. Smith maintained at the hearing that the killings were not caused by a man she had been involved with.

At trial, the prosecution contended that Smith’s motive was a man she was involved with, who reportedly said the children were what stood between them and a shared future. Smith rejected that account on Thursday. Her defence team claimed she had meant to die with the boys but abandoned the car at the final moment.

Opposition from the boys’ father

David Smith, the father of the two boys, attended the hearing to speak for his sons. He said that 32 years had not erased what Smith had done on purpose. He warned the board that releasing her would be deeply unfair to his sons.

Several other people also spoke against her release during the hearing. David Smith has said he will keep opposing any attempt to free her.

How the case unfolded

When the children vanished, Smith reported that a stranger had hijacked her vehicle late one night and driven away. She made public pleas for the boys to be returned safely. Investigators later found the boys in a nearby lake, and Smith eventually confessed.

Smith was found guilty of murder. Back then, state rules let her apply for parole each two years after completing three decades behind bars. Parole means a prisoner can be released before the end of a sentence. Freeing her would have required backing from a larger share of attending members, namely two thirds of them.

What happens next

Because the board voted against her, Smith remains in prison. She can apply again for parole every two years through the South Carolina Board of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services. No new date for a hearing was reported in the BBC article.

The hearing also included several speakers who opposed her release, showing that the case still weighs heavily on those connected to it.

Frequently asked questions

Why was Susan Smith denied parole?

The South Carolina parole board unanimously voted against releasing her at a hearing on Thursday. The decision came 32 years after the killings of her two sons.

Can Susan Smith apply for parole again?

Yes. According to BBC News, Smith can apply to the South Carolina Board of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services every two years.

Who opposed Susan Smithu0026#039;s release?

David Smith, the father of the two boys, attended the hearing and opposed her release. Several other people also spoke against her during the hearing.

Sources

This article was written with the help of AI from reports by the outlets listed above. See our Editorial Policy. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.

About the author

Ravi Franklin

Founder & Editor

Ravi Franklin is the founder and editor of Peak Journalism. His background is in graphic design and digital content, and he started Peak Journalism to make global news clear and easy to follow.