Skip to content
Health

Independent review ordered after NHS Grampian surgery deaths report

A whistleblower says he raised patient safety concerns for years, and the Scottish government now wants to know why they were not acted on.

Peak Journalism news card: Independent review ordered after NHS Grampian surgery deaths report

Key points

  • Scotland's government has commissioned an independent review of liver and pancreatic surgery at NHS Grampian, according to BBC News.
  • A 2022 report found 19 of 31 patient deaths in these operations could have been prevented.
  • Whistleblower Dr Mohammed Habib says he raised concerns with the Scottish government four times.
  • Health Secretary Angela Constance is due to address Holyrood on Tuesday.
  • An external intervention support team will help NHS Grampian improve its services.

Scotland’s government has launched an independent examination of liver and pancreatic operations at NHS Grampian, according to BBC News. The decision came after a whistleblower made public a 2022 document which concluded that 19 of 31 patient deaths in those operations could have been prevented.

Dr Mohammed Habib says he raised his worries with the Scottish government four times. He also took them to the police and to the lord advocate. Habib further alleges that two patients died after receiving the wrong operation, and he is pushing for a corporate homicide inquiry against the health board.

Read also: Aberdeen surgeon seeks homicide probe into NHS Grampian deaths

Scope of the review

Angela Constance, the Scottish health secretary, has said the examination will look at how the health board and the Scottish government dealt with concerns about liver, gallbladder and bile duct procedures, Habib’s among them. It will aim to uncover governance failings, missed chances, unjustified delays and holes in accountability.

Constance called Habib’s worries alarming and extremely serious. She described the review as urgent and wholly independent, and she plans to address Holyrood on Tuesday to outline its timetable and name its leader.

NHS Grampian’s chief executive, Laura Skaife-Knight, promised the board would be honest and open while assisting the inquiry. She also described the review as the most sensible route forward, and said staff would act straight away to safeguard files, paperwork and other material.

Patient experiences and support

Derek Appleton, speaking to BBC Scotland News, said that in effect he had died after an operation on his liver at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary. The surgery removed 60% of the organ after he had been found to have stage four cancer. He believes errors happened during the procedure, yet he says nobody has ever fully explained what went wrong.

He describes a blood loss of 11 litres and a cardiac arrest during the operation. Anyone with concerns can phone 08085 202030, the NHS Grampian helpline, for advice, the health secretary said.

Separately, the government has put together a team of experienced senior NHS managers, known as an external intervention support team. It will work alongside Grampian’s own health staff to bring rapid improvement.

A separate body, Healthcare Improvement Scotland, must carry out an initial assessment of NHS Grampian within three months to measure progress. Further assessments will follow to give ongoing independent oversight.

Political response

Humza Yousaf held the health portfolio when Habib’s report arrived. A spokesperson for Yousaf, who later became first minister and stepped down in May 2024, said he backs full openness and will fully cooperate with any inquiry. The spokesperson added that he supports releasing minutes from that period.

John Swinney, the first minister, has ordered a review into how the government handles letters after saying he only learned of three letters from Habib on Thursday.

Jackie Baillie, Scottish Labour’s health spokeswoman, backed the review, but said a similar failure should never be repeated. She added that families had a right to know who was aware of the problems, when they found out, and why the matter took so long to surface.

Yi-pei Chou Turvey, a Scottish Liberal Democrat MSP for north east Scotland, described families’ wait for answers as agonising. She argued ministers should have pressed NHS Grampian harder after repeated warnings and a report on 19 avoidable deaths, and that the inquiry must establish why Swinney, Yousaf and later health secretaries did not act.

Miles Briggs, the Scottish Conservative health spokesman, warned that the review must not become a way to avoid blame. He said it must establish what information reached ministers and NHS Grampian executives and what was done about it.

Frequently asked questions

Why has the Scottish government ordered a review into NHS Grampian?

A 2022 report concluded that 19 of 31 patient deaths in those liver and pancreatic operations could have been prevented. A whistleblower, Dr Mohammed Habib, released the document and says he raised concerns repeatedly.

What will the NHS Grampian review examine?

The review will examine how the health board and the Scottish government responded to concerns about hepatobiliary surgery. Its scope includes governance failings, missed chances, unjustified delays and accountability gaps.

Who can patients contact for help about NHS Grampian surgery?

Anyone with concerns can phone 08085 202030, the NHS Grampian helpline, for advice, the health secretary said.

Sources

This article was written with the help of AI from reports by the outlets listed above. See our Editorial Policy. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.

About the author

Ravi Franklin

Founder & Editor

Ravi Franklin is the founder and editor of Peak Journalism. His background is in graphic design and digital content, and he started Peak Journalism to make global news clear and easy to follow.