UN talks on autonomous weapons treaty collapse in Geneva
Negotiators failed to agree a binding framework after a week of talks, leaving only a weaker instrument with uncertain legal force.

Key points
- UN talks in Geneva on a binding treaty for autonomous weapons ended without a strong negotiating mandate.
- Russia was described by diplomats as blocking progress, which the Guardian reports as obstructive stalling.
- More than 100 states wanted a new legal protocol, but the consensus rule favoured a weaker option.
- The US and several other military powers were reluctant to accept a legally binding instrument.
- Campaigners said the outcome missed a chance to regulate weapons already in use.
Negotiations at the United Nations in Geneva on controlling autonomous weapons have collapsed, according to The Guardian. The talks, part of the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW), ended shortly before 5am after an all-night session failed to bridge a gap with Russia. Delegates instead agreed to a mandate that may not carry any legal obligations.
Most states at the conference wanted a negotiating mandate that would lead to a legally binding treaty. The CCW works by consensus, however, meaning all 128 parties must agree before a statement can pass. That rule meant the conference fell back on a much weaker option, which asks countries to work on an instrument by consensus.
Why the talks stalled
Russia led the objections, and diplomats said its delegation used stalling tactics and was not negotiating in good faith. Other countries with large investments in AI warfare also held back. The United States, along with South Korea, Japan, Turkey, the UK, France and Germany, were named as defence technology powers that resisted being bound by a new law.
Some governments argued that existing international humanitarian law was enough to cover these weapons. More than 100 states disagreed and said autonomous systems raised entirely new problems. European and Nato states, as well as Ukraine, China and Iran, were reported to have expressed support for, or openness to, a new protocol.
The United States said human control over autonomous weapons had come up in talks between Xi Jinping and Donald Trump at the Apec summit this week. Washington nonetheless remained unwilling to accept a binding treaty. Its proposal of a five-year timeline for a mandate was criticised by campaigners.
Concerns from campaigners and diplomats
Max Tegmark, chair of the Future of Life Institute, said world leaders had failed to rise to the moment. He warned that the weapons were already in existence and that states had chosen to keep discussing the issue for another year. Critics also said the talks had been running for 13 years, and that large parts of a possible treaty were already agreed.
Bonnie Docherty, a senior arms adviser at Human Rights Watch who has worked on past treaties banning cluster munitions and nuclear weapons, said binding law was needed. She argued that a treaty could be negotiated within 15 months. A bloc of seven countries, Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Ireland, Mexico, New Zealand and Panama, had pushed for a binding treaty within one year.
One European diplomat said there had been no real political will to regulate the weapons. The Brazilian delegate told the conference that these were not weapons of the future, since they were already in use and still being developed.
Wider context
The debate comes as Israel and the United States have used AI-enabled targeting systems in strikes in Gaza and Iran, which have caused mass casualties, according to the reports. The Guardian also cited investigative media reports that the US military aims to make 1,000 AI-assisted targeting decisions per hour. Those details have added weight to calls for clear rules.
The conference also saw an unusual protest on its final day. Several nonmember countries were excluded from negotiations, and the Egyptian delegation shouted at the conference chair. Campaigners say the failure to agree a binding framework leaves civilians exposed to autonomous systems, and the next steps remain unclear.
Frequently asked questions
Why did the UN talks on autonomous weapons collapse?
According to The Guardian, the talks in Geneva failed to overcome Russian objections. The conference operates by consensus, so the group adopted a much weaker mandate instead of a binding treaty.
Does the new mandate create legal obligations?
The mandate asks countries to elaborate an instrument by consensus. The Guardian reports that this instrument may not carry any legal obligations.
Which countries opposed a binding treaty?
The Guardian reports that Russia led the objections, while the US, South Korea, Japan, Turkey, the UK, France and Germany were reluctant to be bound by a new law.
Sources
This article was written with the help of AI from reports by the outlets listed above. See our Editorial Policy. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.



