Skip to content
Science

New Method Tests Whether Ancient Light Really Rotated

A new technique aims to separate real cosmic signals from instrument errors. The early results match an existing analysis but do not confirm the effect.

Peak Journalism news card: New Method Tests Whether Ancient Light Really Rotated

Key points

  • Observations suggest the polarization of the cosmic microwave background may have shifted slightly over time.
  • A tiny misalignment in telescope detectors could produce a similar apparent rotation.
  • UC San Diego physicists tested a method comparing detector groups using European Space Agency Planck data.
  • The method matched an established analysis but cannot measure the absolute rotation alone.
  • Confirming the effect could hint at physics beyond the Standard Model.

According to ScienceDaily, physicists have found a possible twist in the oldest light in the universe. The signal may point to a rotation in the polarization of ancient radiation. Scientists stress that the effect has not been confirmed, and a measurement error could explain it.

The light in question is the cosmic microwave background, a faint glow left over from about 380,000 years after the Big Bang. It offers a snapshot of the early universe, which is roughly 13.8 billion years old. When the universe cooled enough to let light pass freely, that radiation gained a small degree of linear polarization.

Recent observations suggest that this polarization may have turned slightly as the light crossed space. Researchers call the possible turning cosmic birefringence. If it is real, it could point to processes that the Standard Model of particle physics does not explain.

A possible signal or an instrument problem?

The main obstacle is the telescope itself. A very small misalignment in the polarization detectors can create a pattern that looks almost the same as cosmic birefringence. If every detector shares the same error, standard measurements cannot tell the two apart.

Physicists at the University of California San Diego, led by Anto I. Lonappan, Brian Keating and Kam Arnold, developed a new way to check this. Their findings were published in The Astrophysical Journal Letters. Instead of relying on one combined measurement, they compared separate polarization maps made by different groups of detectors.

Any rotation shared by all the maps can be removed in this comparison. What remains shows differences in calibration between detector groups. According to the team, this helps reveal inconsistencies that could otherwise confuse the search for new physics.

Testing the method with Planck data

The team analysed eight polarization maps built from observations by the European Space Agency’s Planck satellite. They then compared the results with the established Minami-Komatsu analysis. Although the two methods use different assumptions, they gave consistent answers.

The new approach has a clear limit. It cannot measure the overall polarization angle on its own, so it cannot show how much the universe itself rotated the light. An independent reference is still needed for that. When the researchers combined their results with the common calibration value, they estimated an angle of 0.37 ± 0.12 degrees, matching the existing result.

The researchers note that this match does not independently prove that the light has rotated. It shows the new method can reproduce existing results while offering a separate way to check for calibration problems.

Why it matters for gravitational waves

The technique may also help in the search for gravitational waves from the early universe. Scientists separate polarization patterns into E modes and B modes. A type of B mode produced by primordial gravitational waves would be a strong clue about cosmic inflation, but it has not yet been detected.

A small calibration error could make the much stronger E-mode signal appear as false B modes. Keating, who leads the Simons Observatory work, said the measurement must survive rigorous checks before it can be trusted. According to the researchers, the new framework may help future experiments avoid such mistakes.

  • Dark matter and dark energy jointly represent roughly 95% of all energy in the universe.
  • Some theories link the possible rotation to axion-like particles, which have not been confirmed.
  • Other explanations connect it to fields tied to dark energy.

For now, the main task is to confirm that the signal is genuine. The new method gives researchers another tool to rule out instrument errors before any claim of new physics is made.

Frequently asked questions

What is cosmic birefringence?

Cosmic birefringence is a possible rotation in the polarization of the cosmic microwave background as its light travels across the universe. Observations suggest it may exist, but it has not been confirmed.

Why is a telescope error a problem?

A very slight tilt in how the detectors are oriented can generate a pattern that mimics cosmic birefringence closely. Because the flaw may affect every detector equally, separating it from a true effect is difficult.

Does the new method confirm the universe rotated light?

No. According to the researchers, the method matched an established analysis but does not independently confirm that the ancient light has rotated.

Sources

This article was written with the help of AI from reports by the outlets listed above. See our Editorial Policy. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.

About the author

Ravi Franklin

Founder & Editor

Ravi Franklin is the founder and editor of Peak Journalism. His background is in graphic design and digital content, and he started Peak Journalism to make global news clear and easy to follow.